Economics for bond investment

Good investors understand the importance of diversifying their portfolio by balancing risky and safe investments. Government bonds are generally considered to be among the safest investment assets as governments are less prone to default than corporates. Given the lower risk profile, government bonds offer lower interest payments compared to corporate bonds. However, adding government bonds to one's portfolio is a good hedge against investment volatility.

In this note, I will discuss the various macroeconomic variables to assess when considering investment into government bonds. One formula to familiarize yourself with is the opposite relationship between bond yields and prices. When bond yields go up, bond prices go down and vice versa. Rising bond yields therefore, lower the investment return of bonds.

Are we in a high growth and high inflation phase?

Periods of strong economic growth are generally driven by consumer spending, corporate investment, government spending and/or strong trade performance. Strong economic activity may generate inflationary pressures that force the central bank to hike interest rates and raise bond yields. Moreover, during economic boom, equity investments tend to outperform bond investments as investors are generally optimistic about the business outlook.

As economies are emerging out of the COVID-induced lockdowns, economic growth and inflation have been rising since late 2020. In such an environment, investors would wait until interest rates have peaked (and bond prices have troughed) before re-entering the debt market.

Debt market capital flows in Asia turned negative earlier this year as bond yields and inflation rose. In several economies such as India and Philippines, negative real yields (nominal yields less inflation) dimmed the attractiveness of government bonds.

Quarterly growth and monthly inflation data can be accessed through local statistics agency websites, central bank websites or the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

How is the fiscal profile likely to evolve?

A country's fiscal profile refers to the government's debt and budget deficit to GDP. A highly indebted government may face difficulties in servicing its debt as investors require higher interest payments to hold that debt. A poor fiscal profile deteriorates a country's sovereign credit rating and raises the investment risk of holding government bonds. During the pandemic, India, Malaysia and Philippines among other Asian countries found their sovereign credit rating or outlook downgraded by the rating agencies. This raised concerns among investors and weakened capital inflows into their debt markets.

Having said that, bond investors should concentrate on the trend of fiscal profile rather than absolute levels. For instance, several governments announced medium term fiscal consolidation plans post COVID, to bring their debt under control. Examples include India, Indonesia and Malaysia, where ministries of finance announced medium-term debt and deficit targets to soothe concerns. Fiscal improvements, ceteris paribus, lead to lower yields and better bond returns over the medium term.

Investors should also study the average debt maturity and currency denomination of government debt. Longer maturity profiles reduce the exigency of debt repayments and give governments the time to bring finances in order.

Foreign currency denominated debt is more vulnerable to exchange rate volatility during crisis periods. Indonesia and Philippines have higher proportion of foreign currency denominated debt. During periods of risk-off, these markets are more vulnerable to capital outflow driven by exchange rate depreciation. In this regard, although India's debt and deficit levels are generally higher than Asian peers, long average debt maturity (exceeding 10 years) and largely local currency denominated debt provides important cushion to investors.

Data on fiscal metrics is available on the websites of the ministry of finance, budget office and the IMF.

What are the demand and supply dynamics?

In Econ 101 we learnt that the price of a good is a function of its demand and supply. Similarly, bond prices depend on demand and supply. If demand for bonds is higher than supply, bond price would increase and improve the investment return.

I admit that gaining this information is slightly tedious, but not impossible. You simply need to know where to look.

Bond supply is easier to determine as the budget office or ministry of finance provides this data while promulgating the annual budget. Governments often discuss budget financing through surplus cash reserves and/or additional bond issuance.

Bond demand is onerous to determine as each country differs in its bond holders. Common sources of demand include 1) local insurance firms, 2) local pension funds, 3) local banks, 4) foreigners and 5) the central bank. For instance, in South Korea, the local pension fund called National Pension Service (NPS) is an important investor in Korea Treasury Bonds (KTBs). NPS often discusses its allocation into KTBs and its medium-term plans, which can be accessed on its website. In recent years, NPS announced its intention to raise overseas allocation in search of higher yields. With the Korean population rapidly ageing, NPS has been seeking more lucrative investment opportunities for its depositors. Greater allocation overseas implies lower allocation towards domestic assets such as KTBs. This is long term negative for KTB returns.

Similarly, the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) in Malaysia is a key sources of demand for Malaysian Government Securities (MGS). Amidst the COVID pandemic, the Malaysian government allowed citizens facing economic hardships to withdraw their EPF contributions. These withdrawals reduced EPF's assets under management and affected its MGS investment.

As the pandemic shuttered businesses across nations, banks became risk averse to lending. Rather, they preferred increasing their allocations towards the safety of government bonds. This created additional demand for government bonds and boosted prices. Banks provide data on their government bond investments during quarterly results filing.

For information into government bond holders, I would also recommend going through central bank publications. Central banks often produce deep dives on country bond markets and major bond holders.

Is the central bank assisting the bond market through QE?

Prior to COVID, quantitative easing or QE as a policy tool was used mostly in developed economies facing prolonged periods of low growth and inflation. For further information on QE please refer to this article. The Bank of Japan (BoJ) and European Central Bank (ECB) implemented QE measures to revive growth and inflation amidst demographic decline. Post the global financial crisis in 2008, the US Federal Reserve (Fed) performed QE to stimulate the economy and bank lending.

QE opens up an additional source of demand for bonds in the form of central bank bond purchases. The COVID pandemic forced several developing economy central banks to implement QE measures. These were aimed at 1) easing liquidity conditions for consumers and businesses affected by the pandemic and 2) financing governments' stimulus measures by lowering bond yields.

Several Asian central banks undertook QE measures including the Reserve Bank of India, Bank Indonesia, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas and Bank of Thailand among others. Central banks publish data on asset purchases on their websites.

As fiscal stimulus deteriorated government' fiscal profile, central banks mollified bond investors by purchasing government bonds and assisting government finances.

How is the currency outlook?

In a previous post, I touched upon the importance of currency return in the overall return of an asset. Foreign investors must incorporate the currency outlook when investing overseas. Suppose you are a US based investor and have invested in Indian government bonds. Over a period of time, the investment returned 15% through capital gains. However, over the same period, the Indian Rupee depreciated 10% against the US Dollar. In that case, your total return would be 15-10 = 5% from this investment.

Therefore, having some idea about where the currency is headed will add to the thoroughness of your investment analysis. Please refer to this post for case studies on currencies.

Conclusion

Government bonds are safe investment bets and considered to be good portfolio diversifiers. In order to assess the pros and cons of investing in this asset class, you can examine readily available economic variables. These include

1) Economic growth and inflation - higher growth and inflation raise government bond yields and lower bond prices.

2) The country's fiscal policy - improving fiscal outlook through lower fiscal deficit and debt over the medium term, ceteris paribus lower government bond yields.

3) Demand and supply dynamics - knowing the major holders of government bonds by country is a great first step in comparing demand and supply for bonds. Information on bond demand and supply can be found on central bank or ministry of finance websites.

4) Central bank asset purchases or QE - Another source of bond demand is the country's central bank. In Japan, the BoJ holds over 40% of outstanding Japanese Government Bonds (JGBs). This policy is aimed at lowering interest rates to boost bank lending, growth and inflation.

5) Currency outlook - investors should incorporate currency views into their investment analysis when investing overseas. Refer to my previous posts on currency discussions.

Currency case studies

This post is a follow-up to my previous article, which laid out the economic framework to forecast currency performance. In that note, I had emphasized on the importance of currency evaluation in the investment decision making process. Currency returns need to be accounted for in the overall investment return and simple economic variables can be utilized to make an assessment about a currency’s direction over the investment horizon.

We identified 7 economic and policy variables to guide the currency outlook. In this note, we will apply the variables to forecast actual currencies. These case studies will assist you in building your thought process around currencies, when to buy and sell them and how to apply economic variables to understand the market. Please note that currency forecasting based on economic fundamentals is appropriate for medium to long term forecasting and identifying currency cycles.

The US Dollar is likely to weaken:

The USD is the most traded currency in the global economy. In 2019, the USD was involved in 88% of all FX transactions. Additionally, as the global reserve currency, the dollar is held by almost all central banks and institutional investment firms. Given the importance of the USD in the global FX market, we start applying our economic framework to forecast its direction.

1. US trade balance is likely to worsen: The United States has historically seen trade deficits (where imports > exports) since 1992. It is a consumption-based economy, relying on imports to fulfill domestic demand. As the US economy is exiting the pandemic, pent up consumer demand is likely to boost imports and worsen the trade deficit. This should weaken the USD.

2. US capital account balance is likely to worsen: The United States is the largest source of private sector capital in the world economy. As a response to the economic shock from COVID-19, the US Federal Reserve (Fed) slashed policy interest rates to 0% in 2020. With domestic interest rates at record low, US based investment firms have the incentive to allocate capital overseas in search of higher yields. This is likely to worsen US’ capital account balance and weaken the USD.

3. The Fed will allow inflation to run high: In August 2020, Fed Chair Jerome Powell announced an important shift in the Fed’s monetary policy. Since 2012, the Fed had been targeting 2% inflation. In August 2020, Chair Powell tweaked the Fed’s inflation targeting mandate from long-term inflation targeting to average long-term inflation targeting at 2%. Quoting Chair Powell – “following periods when inflation has been running below 2 percent, appropriate monetary policy will likely aim to achieve inflation moderately above 2 percent for some time”.

This shift in monetary policy is important because it suggests that the Fed will let inflation exceed 2% in some time periods, as long as inflation averages 2% over the long term. With pent up demand in the US coming back, higher US inflation is likely to weaken the USD.

4. US money supply growth is at a historic high: In response to the COVID-19-induced economic shock, the US government and central bank unveiled massive stimulus programs. These were aimed at boosting consumer spending and private investment. At the same time, the stimulus measures pushed M2 money supply growth to a historic high of 24.8% y/y in December 2020!! To provide you some context, M2 money supply during GFC peaked at 10% y/y in March 2012. Such high money supply growth is likely to weaken the USD.

As per our framework, the USD is likely to weaken.

In the subsequent case study, we will assess the currency’s direction relative to the USD.

Korean Won’s fundamentals have been improving.

1. Korea’s trade balance is improving: Semiconductors comprise ~20% of Korean exports. Semiconductor prices are cyclical in nature, with each cycle generally lasting 2 years. The last cycle bottomed out in August 2020 and the pandemic has simultaneously boosted demand for electronic products made using semis. This suggests that semiconductor prices are likely to rise over the next 1-2 years and boost Korean exports. This will strengthen the KRW.

2. Korean inflation is below US inflation:

Ageing demographics is an important driver of lower Korean CPI. In 2020, Korea's fertility rate fell to 0.84, the lowest globally. This compares against 1.73 in the US and 1.42 in Japan. Korea's population fell for the first time in 2020, suggesting a downtrend in consumption and inflationary pressure in the economy over the coming years.

Relative to the US where the Fed may let inflation run high, Korean CPI is likely to be weak due to structural factors. This will weaken the USD against KRW.

3. US money supply exceeds Korean money supply: Against 18% y/y M2 money supply growth in the US (after peaking at 25% last year), Korean money supply peaked at 11% y/y. Lower Korean money supply is likely to strengthen the KRW against the USD.

4. The Bank of Korea is likely to hike the policy rate soon: To provide you some context here, the BoK is a conservative central bank. By conservative, I mean that it has hawkish tendencies and is averse to extra loose monetary policy conditions. Such conditions lead to macro prudential risks such as asset bubbles. The BoK is especially concerned about rising house prices in Korea and household debt being over 100% to GDP. With the economy reverting to normal post the 2020 crisis, the BoK sounded hawkish at its last policy meeting. An eventual policy rate hike will strengthen the KRW.

Currency forecasting is simpler than we think it is. Sure currencies are volatile and prone to swings due to everyday events. But economic fundamentals can guide the medium to long term currency outlook and help look through the daily, weekly or even monthly volatility. Moreover, economic analysis can help enhance the investment decision making process for trading FX and other asset classes across economies.

Key takeaways:

1. Our analysis of the US Dollar (USD) based on the economic variables indicates that the USD should weaken in the medium term.

2. On the other hand, the same variables suggest Korean Won (KRW) appreciation.

3. Similar analysis on currencies can be utilized to identify attractive currency pairs where one currency has strong fundamentals and one weak. FX traders often use such analysis to go long (buy) and short (sell) currencies to make gains.

Using everyday economics to forecast currency movements

Currency forecasting is a useful exercise to complement investment decision making. Suppose as an investor, you are keen on gaining exposure to emerging or frontier markets for their growth potential. Financial and economic analysis will be the key inputs in the decision making. However, investors often forget that the final investment return will factor in the currency appreciation or depreciation of the investment asset as well.

If you are keen on making currency trades, timing the cycle of the currency and knowing its future direction will be important. Part 2 to this post will more directly address this question.

With these questions in mind, this article is a primer on using simple economic variables to forecast the direction of currency movement. I have provided data sources that are freely accessible, for your reference. By the end, you will have a good idea about how to approach currency forecasting without doing a PhD in economics!

1. Rising trade balance strengthens the currency

The trade balance measures the difference between the value of exports and imports of goods and services of a country. A positive trade balance reflects exports exceeding imports. When Singapore's exports are booming, there is rising global demand for its products. Higher demand pushes up the price of Singapore's goods and strengthens the Singapore Dollar (SGD) in the process.

When Singapore's imports exceed its exports, domestic participants are demanding foreign products, driving up the prices of foreign goods and weakening the SGD relative to foreign currencies.

Relevant example: In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Taiwan and Korea’s currencies outperformed peers (against the USD) in the region. Despite weak global demand, Taiwan and Korea offered products that were highly demanded at the time—work from home electronics. This boosted Taiwanese and Korean exports while their imports lagged due to weak domestic spending.

Data source: Trade statistics are published by trade ministries or national statistics offices.

2. Rising capital account balance strengthens the currency

A country’s capital account reflects the difference between capital inflow (in the form of inward investment by foreigners) and capital outflow (investment by domestic players abroad). The capital account is in surplus when a country receives more foreign capital investment than what it invests abroad. Capital account surplus strengthens a currency by augmenting investor appetite for domestic assets.

Relevant example: Walmart opening a factory in India is direct investment whereas Walmart’s investment team buying Indian stocks or bonds is portfolio investment. Either type of investment in Indian assets strengthens the Indian Rupee (INR).

Domestic asset managers’ investment strategy is a useful leading indicator of capital account dynamics. For example, Korea’s National Pension Service (NPS, Korea’s largest investor) announced its intention to enhance foreign asset allocation to boost investment returns. This would imply capital outflow from Korea and Korean Won (KRW) weakness.

Data source: Central banks publish data on portfolio and direct investment inflows. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) publishes capital flow data by country here.

3. Higher domestic inflation weakens the currency

Inflation refers to the rise in the price of goods and services in the local economy, over a period of time. When inflation increases, 1 unit of local currency can purchase fewer goods and services. This weakens the purchasing power of the local currency.

Relevant example: Emerging market economies such as Argentina, Brazil, India and the Philippines have seen their currencies weaken against the US Dollar (USD) over time, given that their inflation is higher than the US.

Data source: The national statistics agencies and central banks publish inflation data monthly or quarterly. The IMF’s World Economic Outlook database and the World Bank’s macro data pages contain a compendium of macroeconomic data by country.

4. Central bank policy rate hike causes currency appreciation

The central bank sets the country’s monetary policy. It decides the rate at which domestic banks borrow from it. As the central bank’s policy rate is the benchmark for other debt instruments in the economy (loans, bonds), domestic interest rates increase when the central bank hikes the policy rate. With domestic interest rates rising, foreign investors may take advantage of the higher policy rate by investing in the local debt instruments which now offer higher interest income. Foreign capital inflows seeking higher return in the domestic economy, lead to currency appreciation (as per point 2 above).

Relevant example: When the US Federal Reserve and European Central Bank (ECB) slashed policy rates during the global financial crisis in 2008, foreign investors seeking higher yield income, rushed to buy emerging market debt.

Data source: Central banks release their monetary policy statements on their websites. These statements provide useful economic snapshots and central bankers often comment on currency dynamics.

5. Higher money supply on a relative basis weakens the currency

Money is supplied into the economy through the government or central bank. When the government expands its expenditure plans, it pumps money into the economy. When the central bank lowers the policy rate at which banks borrow from it, banks lower lending rates and make it cheaper to borrow funds. This raises money in circulation. When supply of money exceeds demand, the purchasing power of currency in circulation weakens. In other words, too much money chases too few goods. There are several measures of money supply termed M1, M2, M3 and M4. The most practical term for our analysis is M2 which represents money in circulation (cash and coins), deposits made into savings accounts, money market securities and time deposits.

Relevant example: As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and economic shock, the US Federal Reserve and government introduced significant stimulus into the economy. Both fiscal and monetary policy measures raised the currency in circulation. On a relative basis, the growth rate of M2 in the US (yearly or monthly basis) exceeded South Korea as the degree of stimulus in the US was far greater than in Korea. This implied that the USD should weaken again the Korean Won (KRW).

Data source: Data on M2 is available on central bank websites. Readers should compare M2 growth (y/y or m/m) rather than M2 levels. CEIC provides free data on M2 growth by country.

6. Central bank’s intervention to weaken the currency

Before we discuss central bank policies, we should link currency strength and weakness to imports and exports. In section 1, we observed that a rising trade balance strengthens the currency against its main trade partners. A stronger currency indicates that 1 unit of foreign currency will be able to purchase fewer goods from the exporting country, thereby reducing its exports. Central banks may be wary of sharp currency appreciation and its offsetting impact on exports.

Relevant example: In 2020, several Asian central banks implemented policies to prevent currency appreciation against the USD in order to maintain export competitiveness. The Indian central bank (RBI) prevented the rupee from appreciating by buying USD and shoring up its FX reserves. FX reserves build up is a good indicator of central bank intervention.

The central banks of China and Vietnam manage their currency within a band or by pegging the level. The Thai central bank eased policies to boost capital outflows in order to weaken the Baht. Sometimes governments may exert pressure on the domestic asset managers to allocate funds abroad in order to generate capital account outflows (see section 2 on capital account dynamics) and weaken the currency. Korea’s National Pension Service comes to mind.

The easiest way to understand central banks’ policy biases is by reading their commentaries, monetary policy statements and policy announcements.

Data source: FX reserves data is available on central bank websites as well as the IMF. The US Treasury’s semi-annual FX report provides useful analysis of the FX policies of US’ important trade partners.

7. Real effective exchange rate

The REER assesses a currency's value against the weighted average of other currencies of the country’s major trade partners. Rising REER indicates currency strengthening. This reduces export competitiveness.

Data source: The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) compiles REER indices for 60 countries, here. In the dataset, 2010 is considered to be the base year and BIS provides REER values for the past 5 years. You can compare the REER in the current month to its value over the past 5 years as well as against 2010. This exercise will indicate whether the currency is over or under- valued relative to its own history. REER indices help traders forecast the future movement of currencies towards their fair value.

Key takeaways from the article:

1. Currency forecasting can complement investment decision making, by helping investors identify regions or countries having good currency outlook. This can help investors narrow down their investment options.

2. Although currency performance is uncertain and dependent on various factors, simple economic concepts can be used to make judgements on the direction of currency movement.

3. The economic variables assessed in this article include trade balance, capital account balance and inflation among others. All variables are freely available on central bank websites and macroeconomic databases.